Zillow warns the housing market is heading into its worst stretch yet
Buying a house in America has become an expensive game of "maybe next year." Unfortunately, Zillow thinks November could make things even worse before the housing market finally catches its breath.
November could be the housing market's roughest month yet
Zillow's latest numbers suggest the slowdown is not just a seasonal wobble. Newly pending listings, which track homes that have gone under contract but haven't officially closed, dropped nearly 17% compared with October last year. October also recorded the slowest pace of pending sales for that month since 2018.
Existing-home sales weren't doing much better, falling nearly 10% year over year. Zillow's chief economist Mischa Fisher told Moneywise that he expects November to deliver an even bigger contraction before the slowdown begins easing into the new year.
Redfin is picking up similar signals. Its October figures showed home sales declining month over month for the first time in three years. The median sale price also slipped year over year, marking its first annual decline since May 2023. Redfin economist Dana Anderson pointed to mortgage rates climbing above 7% as a major factor behind the slowdown, although flattening home prices could eventually offer buyers some relief.
So, this isn't simply a case of Americans suddenly losing interest in homeownership. A lot of them are being priced out of it.
Mortgage payments are making homeownership harder to justify
The biggest villain in this housing story is still the mortgage rate. The average 30-year mortgage rate reached 7.4% in early October, its highest level in nearly three years. That's a considerable jump from the 5.98% average recorded in late February.
Higher borrowing costs have made an already expensive housing market considerably harder to navigate. Zillow estimates that the typical monthly mortgage payment reached $2,004 in October, even with a 20% down payment. That's nearly 13% higher than a year earlier, and the figure doesn't include property taxes or homeowners insurance.
The increase from September was also the biggest monthly jump in four years. Once taxes, insurance and maintenance enter the picture, a median-income household would spend more than 40% of its income on housing costs, compared with roughly 39% a year earlier.
In all of this, there has been some recent relief. Freddie Mac reported that the average 30-year mortgage rate dropped to approximately 7.11% on November 12, marking its fourth consecutive weekly decline.
But we can’t mistake a small dip for an affordability miracle. On a $400,000 loan, borrowers could still pay roughly $300 more each month compared with borrowing when rates were just below 6%. And with persistent inflation raising concerns about another Federal Reserve rate increase, buyers should not assume cheaper mortgages are just around the corner.
Renting is starting to look like the better deal
Buying isn't just expensive compared with what Americans paid a few years ago. In many places, it has become significantly more expensive than renting. Zillow estimates that purchasing a typical single-family home now requires $14,408 more in annual income than renting one. That is a substantial difference for households already dealing with rising everyday expenses.
Zillow economist Kara Ng argues that renting a house can be a legitimate financial strategy for people who don't want to stretch their budgets to buy. The company also estimates that buyers need to stay in a home for approximately 7.8 years before purchasing becomes financially preferable to renting. That makes the usual pressure to buy as soon as possible a little harder to defend.
If you are paying substantially more each month to own a property, you need to consider how long you will actually stay there before the numbers make sense. For some households, renting and keeping the difference in savings may be a better move than rushing into a mortgage.
Buyers finally have more room to play hardball
With fewer people competing for properties and more houses sitting on the market, buyers are getting something they haven't had much of in recent years: leverage. Fisher says buyers have more properties to choose from in most markets than they have had in years. That means fewer bidding wars and more opportunities to negotiate with sellers.
The shift is already visible across major U.S. cities. According to Redfin, just three of the country's 50 largest metropolitan areas are currently seller's markets, while 41 favor buyers.
Don't wait for mortgage rates to magically drop
If you are planning to take advantage of the softer market, getting your financing sorted out matters just as much as finding the right property. Freddie Mac research suggests borrowers could benefit from collecting as many as five mortgage quotes when shopping for a lender. Comparing offers can help secure a better interest rate, but buyers also need to examine the fees attached to each loan.
Closing costs typically run between 2% and 5% of the loan amount, which means a seemingly attractive interest rate could come with expensive strings attached. And waiting for mortgage rates to fall below 6% might not be the winning strategy some buyers are hoping for.
Housing economists have become less optimistic about a major decline in borrowing costs, with persistent inflation and the possibility of further Federal Reserve tightening limiting the chances of significant relief. HousingWire's tracking also suggests housing activity tends to weaken as 30-year mortgage rates approach 7%, while demand generally improves when rates fall below approximately 6.64%.
The housing market is cooling, but the opportunity isn't for everyone
Zillow's warning does not mean home prices are about to collapse or that every buyer should rush out and make an offer. November could bring another significant drop in housing activity, but Fisher expects the slowdown to ease into the new year. Meanwhile, the combination of elevated mortgage rates and expensive homeownership will continue to keep plenty of households on the sidelines.
Still, the shift in bargaining power is worthy of note. Sellers are facing fewer competing buyers, homes are staying available longer and prospective homeowners finally have more room to question asking prices instead of immediately scrambling to outbid someone else. The irony is that America's housing market may be getting more welcoming to buyers just as fewer Americans can afford to participate. For anyone with solid financing and enough money saved, that could create opportunities that were much harder to find during the recent seller-dominated market.